Both the Blundstone #558 and #585 Women's Classics Chelsea Boots are highly rated and beloved for their blend of durability, comfort, and timeless style. However, there are distinct differences that can help you decide which pair suits your needs best.
Design and Aesthetic
-
#558 Black Chelsea Boots: Feature a sleek, classic black premium leather with a polished look, ideal for a versatile, business-casual style that pairs well with many outfits.
-
#585 Rustic Brown Chelsea Boots: Crafted from nubuck leather in a rich rustic brown, offering a rugged yet refined appearance that ages beautifully with time and wear.
Price: $199.99
Price: $199.95
Leather and Materials
-
#558: Uses soft, supple 1.8mm premium leather with a leather lining, providing a more relaxed fit and quicker break-in period. The leather is smooth and polished.
-
#585: Made with nubuck leather, which has a velvety texture but requires more care to maintain. It also features full leather lining for warmth and comfort.
Comfort and Fit
-
Both boots include Blundstone’s SPS Max Comfort system with XRD technology in the heel for superior shock absorption and cushioned footbeds.
-
The #558 offers a slightly more cushioned outsole and an extra set of footbeds for a customizable fit.
-
The #585 is noted for its roomy interior and immediate comfort out of the box, favored by those with wider feet or who want less break-in time.
-
Both have elastic side panels and pull tabs for easy slip-on and off.
Durability and Use
-
The #558 is described as a “turned up to the max” version of the Original boots, with enhanced durability and comfort, making it a dependable everyday boot.
-
The #585 is “most admired for a reason,” known for outstanding shock absorption and durability but with a slightly softer, more casual ruggedness.
-
The #558’s leather is more resistant to wear and creasing, while the #585’s nubuck leather may require more maintenance but offers a unique aesthetic.
Customer Feedback
-
Both models boast 5-star ratings, with the #585 having more reviews (364 vs. 151), indicating widespread popularity.
-
Users often praise the #585 for its comfort and fit, especially for those with wider feet or who dislike a long break-in period.
-
The #558 is favored for its classic look and durability, suitable for both casual and more formal occasions.
Which Should You Choose?
-
Choose the Blundstone #558 Black Chelsea Boots if you want a sleek, polished look with enhanced durability and a slightly more formal style.
-
Opt for the Blundstone #585 Rustic Brown Chelsea Boots if you prefer a rugged, casual style with immediate comfort and a boot that develops character over time.
Both boots deliver Blundstone’s signature quality, comfort, and ease of wear, making either an excellent choice depending on your style preference and intended use.
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
Deal pricing and availability subject to change after time of publication.
